-
LOCATION:HOME >> NEWS >> Industry news
-
Industry news
A Column Is Sized by Its Length, Not by Its Grade
A six metre column is a length problem before it is a grade problem
Ask why a portal frame column is uprated to a higher grade and the answer comes back as a yield strength. Ask why there is a knee brace at mid height and the answer gets shorter. Both lines are on the same drawing, but only one of them decides what the member can carry. An H-section used as a column is a compression member first and a grade second, and compression members go sideways. The Euler expression contains no yield term at all. Everything a buyer argues about on a quote sits in the term it leaves out.
Read the size row as a range, not as a section
The Q235 H-beam listing prints flange widths from 50 to 400 mm, flange thicknesses from 8 to 64 mm, web widths from 100 to 900 mm, web thicknesses from 4.5 to 6 mm, and lengths from 6 to 12 m, with a tolerance of plus or minus one per cent and the application given as building, bridges and road. Those are the bounds of what the mill will roll, not one section. Nothing in that row states a second moment of area, and the second moment of area is what the column is actually bought for.
Pick a section inside the range: 300 mm deep, 150 mm flanges, a 6 mm web and 10 mm flanges. Working up from the plate thicknesses is the only way to turn that row into a stiffness.
One section, two radii of gyration
The area is two flanges of 150 by 10 plus a web of 280 by 6, which is 4,680 mm2. At 7,850 kg per cubic metre that is 36.7 kg per metre, so a 6 m stick weighs about 220 kg. The strong-axis second moment of area works out near 74.1 million mm4, giving a radius of gyration of 126 mm. About the weak axis the same steel returns 5.63 million mm4 and 34.7 mm. The weak-axis radius is barely a quarter of the strong one. A column does not choose the comfortable axis; it buckles about the one with the smaller number.
What the grade does and does not buy
With pinned ends and a 6 m unbraced length, the Euler load on the weak axis is pi squared times 206,000 N/mm2 times 5.63 million mm4 over 6,000 mm squared, or roughly 318 kN. Divide that by the area and the average stress at buckling is 68 MPa. That is well below the 235 MPa that Q235 is named for, which confirms the elastic formula: the member has gone sideways while the steel is still elastic.
The squash load, area times yield, is 1,100 kN. Move to Q345 and it becomes 1,615 kN, a 47 per cent improvement that buys nothing at all, because the column still leaves the straight line at 318 kN. E is the same 206 GPa in both grades. Grade changes the ceiling; length and stiffness set the floor.
One brace is worth three grade changes
Halve the unbraced length to 3,000 mm and the Euler load quadruples to 1,272 kN. It now sits above the Q235 squash load, so strength finally governs and the member is good for 1,100 kN. A single line of restraint has taken the capacity from 318 to 1,100 kN, a factor of 3.5, at the cost of a few metres of knee brace, tie tube and round-bar bracing. The same page lists them as Q235B circular pipe, angle and round bar. Nobody orders a higher grade for the bracing.
K is decided on the foundation, not in the mill
The effective length factor is the second lever and it is entirely a site detail. A pinned base gives K of 1.0 and the 318 kN above. Fix the base properly and K falls to about 0.7, which nearly doubles the Euler load to 650 kN. Leave the top free as a cantilever and K is 2.0, which quarters it to about 79 kN. The base plate weld and the anchor group, not the steel certificate, separate those three cases. A folded or welded end detail that cannot develop the assumed fixity quietly turns a fixed-base calculation into a pinned one.
The web can fold before the column bows
Overall buckling is not the only instability. The 280 mm web at 6 mm has a depth-to-thickness ratio of about 47, comfortable for a Q235 compression panel. The catalogue range is less reassuring: web widths up to 900 mm sit alongside web thicknesses down to 4.5 mm on the same row, and pairing those extremes gives a ratio near 200. The A36 H-beam page calls the web relatively thin but strong enough to support the weight of the structure, which is a statement about vertical bending, not about a compressed plate panel. The order has to fix both numbers; a depth without a web thickness moves the failure into the plate between the flanges.
Sheeting restrains the purlin only if it can transfer shear
Roof members are the C and Z purlins on the galvanized frame schedule, with PPGI sheet or sandwich panel above them. A corrugated profile is described as resisting bending, warping and buckling because its ridges and valleys add rigidity; that is stiffness in the sheet's own plane. It becomes restraint for the purlin only when the fasteners do not slip and the sheet can act as a diaphragm. A single-skin cladding screwed through the crest is a different structural proposition from a bonded sandwich panel. Assume the restraint and the purlin is designed on its short axis; lose it at a lap or a rooflight and the unbraced length jumps back to the full bay.
A one per cent tolerance is a three per cent stiffness tolerance
The plus or minus one per cent in the size row is worth reading twice. Weak-axis inertia here is dominated by the flange width cubed, so a flange rolled 1 per cent narrow removes about 3 per cent of the weak-axis second moment and 3 per cent of the Euler load. The same 1 per cent on yield strength removes 1 per cent of a ceiling the column never reaches. Dimensional tolerance is a stability tolerance, measured on the delivered section rather than on the certificate.
What the order has to say
Write the four section dimensions, the length, and the grade in that order, then add the lines that govern: the assumed effective length factor and base fixity, the positions of braces and tie tubes, the web thickness wherever a deep section is chosen, and the cladding fixing detail that justifies restraint. Add the coating separately, whether that is a hot-dip galvanized beam or alkyd paint per the frame schedule, because protection does not appear in the buckling sum either. The circular pipe used for bracing and the lighter I-sections used for secondary framing belong on the same drawing with their own restraint assumptions. There is a reason the older handbooks spend more pages on effective length than on yield strength.